Personal Injury Case Manager: Duties, KPIs and Remote Setup
November 9, 2026 · 7 min read

What a personal injury case manager does from intake to settlement, how to handle medical records carefully, which KPIs to track, and how remote support fits.
A personal injury case manager keeps a PI file moving from intake to settlement. They onboard new clients, open insurance claims, track medical treatment, request and organize medical records and bills, assemble the demand package for attorney review, and keep the client updated throughout. Almost all of this work is done on the phone, by email and in your case management software, which is why a remote case manager can handle it well when the firm sets up secure systems and supervision.
This guide walks through the case lifecycle, what can and cannot be done remotely, how to handle medical records carefully, and which KPIs to track.
What a personal injury case manager does at each stage
1. Intake and onboarding
Once an attorney accepts a case, the case manager:
- Sends the engagement agreement and authorizations for e-signature
- Collects the accident report, photos, insurance cards, witness details and the client's provider list
- Opens the matter in your case management system (Filevine, Clio, MyCase, CASEpeer or similar) and builds the task plan
- Explains to the client what happens next and how often they will hear from the firm
2. Claims setup
- Sends letters of representation to the at-fault carrier and the client's own carrier
- Opens property damage, MedPay or PIP claims where applicable
- Records claim numbers, adjuster contacts and policy limits information as it comes in
- Identifies health insurance, Medicare, Medicaid or ERISA plans that may assert liens
3. Treatment monitoring
This is the longest phase and where files most often go quiet. The case manager:
- Checks in with the client on a set schedule about appointments, symptoms and gaps in care
- Keeps a running list of every provider and date of service
- Flags treatment gaps, missed appointments or new providers to the attorney
- Tracks lost wages and collects employer verification
4. Medical records and bills
- Sends records and billing requests to each provider with a signed HIPAA authorization
- Follows up on a calendar until every request is fulfilled
- Checks what arrives against the provider list and dates of service so nothing is missing
- Organizes records chronologically and prepares a treatment summary for attorney or paralegal review
- Builds a medical specials summary from the itemized bills
5. Demand package
The case manager assembles the package; the attorney decides what it says and what to ask for. A typical package includes:
- Liability facts and supporting documents
- A treatment chronology and summary
- Organized medical records and itemized bills
- Proof of lost wages and other economic losses
- Photos and other evidence of injury and impact
The attorney drafts or approves the demand letter and sets the demand amount.
6. Negotiation support
- Logs offers and counteroffers and calendars response deadlines
- Keeps the client informed of each development, as directed by the attorney
- Requests updated records or bills if treatment continues
7. Settlement and disbursement
- Requests final lien amounts and tracks lien reduction requests the attorney makes
- Prepares draft settlement statements for attorney review
- Coordinates release signing and tracks receipt of funds
- Closes the file and sends closing documents
If negotiations fail, the case manager typically hands off to a litigation paralegal or continues in support of the litigation team.
What can be done remotely, and what cannot
Nearly everything above is phone, email, portal and software work, so it can be done remotely. Things that do require someone in person or an attorney:
- In-person tasks: client meetings at the office, picking up physical evidence, original documents that must be handled physically
- Attorney-only decisions: accepting the case, giving legal advice, setting the demand amount, approving or recommending a settlement, signing pleadings and settlement statements, and making disbursement decisions from trust
Under ABA Model Rule 5.3, the firm must make reasonable efforts to ensure its nonlawyer staff act consistently with the lawyers' obligations, and ABA Formal Opinion 498 makes clear those supervisory duties are not reduced when staff work remotely. Check your state bar's rules as well.
Handling medical records with HIPAA in mind
Medical records are the most sensitive documents in a PI file, so it is worth getting the details right.
Use a valid authorization. Under 45 CFR 164.508, a valid HIPAA authorization needs, among other things, a specific description of the information, who may disclose it, who may receive it, the purpose, an expiration date or event, and the client's signature and date. Providers often reject authorizations that miss an element, which delays the file. Have your case manager check each one before it goes out.
Know the provider's timeline. When patients request their own records, HIPAA generally gives the provider 30 days to act, with one 30-day extension if the provider explains the delay in writing. Calendar follow-ups accordingly rather than waiting.
Understand your firm's status. A plaintiff's firm getting records through its own client's authorization is generally not acting as a HIPAA business associate of the provider. The situation can differ if the firm does work for a health care provider or insurer. Either way, your state bar's confidentiality rules apply to client information, and many firms choose to follow HIPAA-style safeguards for all medical records. If you are unsure of your firm's status, get advice from a health privacy lawyer.
Practical safeguards for a remote case manager:
- Records stay in your case management system or document storage, never on personal devices or personal email
- Individual logins with multi-factor authentication and access limited to assigned matters
- Secure portals or encrypted email for sending records to adjusters and experts
- A written confidentiality agreement and short training on handling health information
- Prompt removal of access when someone leaves
KPIs to track for a PI case manager
You do not need a dashboard full of metrics. These few show whether files are moving:
| KPI | What it tells you |
|---|---|
| Days from signup to letters of representation sent | How fast claims get opened |
| Days since last client contact, per file | Whether clients are being kept informed |
| Open records requests older than 30 days | Where files are stuck |
| Days from end of treatment to demand sent | The biggest bottleneck in most PI practices |
| Files with an unflagged treatment gap | Whether case value risks are being caught |
| Active files per case manager | Workload and when to hire |
Set your own targets based on your current baseline; there is no universal standard. Review the numbers in a short weekly meeting with the supervising attorney.
How a dedicated remote case manager fits
Many PI firms find the case manager role is where they get stuck: attorneys end up chasing records and returning status calls themselves, and demands go out later than they should. A dedicated remote case manager can take over that ongoing follow-up work inside your systems, while your attorneys keep the decisions.
Legal Staff Up places dedicated, full-time virtual case managers at $2,199 per month. They work only for your firm, are trained on tools such as Filevine, Clio and MyCase, and are typically onboarded in about seven days, with bilingual options for Spanish-speaking clients. See how we support personal injury firms, or pair a case manager with a virtual paralegal for records summaries and demand drafting. Full role pricing is on our pricing page.
Frequently asked questions
What does a personal injury case manager do?
They manage the day-to-day progress of PI files: onboarding clients, opening claims, monitoring treatment, requesting medical records and bills, assembling demand packages for attorney review, and keeping clients informed. The attorney handles legal advice, demand amounts and settlement decisions.
Can a personal injury case manager work remotely?
Yes. Most case management work is done by phone, email, portals and case management software. The firm needs secure systems, clear procedures and an attorney supervising the work.
What is the difference between a PI case manager and a paralegal?
The case manager focuses on moving the file and communicating with clients, providers and adjusters. A paralegal typically does more substantive work such as summarizing medical records, drafting demand letters for attorney review and supporting litigation. Smaller firms often combine the roles.
Is a law firm covered by HIPAA when it requests medical records?
A plaintiff's firm requesting records with its client's authorization is generally not a covered entity or business associate in that situation. Firms that do work for providers or insurers may be. Your state's confidentiality rules apply either way, so handle records with strong safeguards and get specialist advice if unsure.
How many cases can one PI case manager handle?
It depends on case mix, how far along files are and how much support the case manager has. Track active files per person and the KPIs above, and add capacity when records requests and client contacts start slipping.
Next step
If your attorneys are chasing records and returning status calls instead of negotiating, a dedicated case manager can take that work off their plates. We will introduce pre-vetted PI case managers you can interview for free. Book a free consultation.


